Music critic Anatoli Akvilev wrote after the concert of Lwów State Philharmonic Orchestra under Isaac Pain, held on 15 January 1941, that Joyful Overture testifies ‘merely to formal expertise. [...] It contains many technically sophisticated turns, but little heartfelt warmth. It breathes an air of scholastic cold’ (‘Концерт львівських композиторів’ [A Concert by Lviv Composers], Вiльна Украıнa, 19 Jan. 1941, 6). In a postwar text, Zofia Lissa (A Tribute to Józef Koffler, Poland’s First Dodecaphonist, typescript for a radio broadcast, 1963) suggests that the Overture marked ‘a sudden turn towards the Neoromantic style’. Maciej Gołąb, however, argues that, as in Symphony No. 4, Op. 26, in the Overture Koffler adhered to his modernist aspirations.